The US dollar waxes and wanes in strength against
foreign countries. While it is tempting to feel a surge of pride
in a strong dollar, it is not good for the US economy or our balance
of trade. As the table below indicates, and we know it is somewhat
over-simplified, a prolonged strong dollar hurts US manufacturers
and costs US jobs, while a weaker dollar increases US exports, adds
US jobs and makes the US economy stronger. This seems counter-intuitive,
because shouldn't a surging dollar equal a strong US economy? The
answer is no, as explained below.
As regards US foreign trade, the two major currencies
concerning us are the Euro (now the official
currency of the European Union) and the Japanese Yen.
While other Asian economies are growing rapidly, such as India
and China, their effect on the US and reciprocal trade are not
yet nearly as significant as the yen. The weakening of the dollar
is exciting news for US manufacturers, who are in line for a bonanza
of foreign buying of US goods.
Generally, the dollar has been weakening against
both the Euro and the yen (and most other major currencies) since
mid-2002. Recently, the Euro hit an all-time high against the
dollar; it took $1.29 to buy a single Euro. The yen has been showing
similar strength. Other countries are taking steps to keep their
currencies weak against the dollar. Why? Because if the dollar
is allowed to continue to weaken against their own currencies,
the foreign countries will see the US markets dry up for their
exports as their goods become too expensive for Americans. The
strong dollar through early 2002 resulted in a large trade gap,
with the balance of trade against the US - that is, we were importing
more than we exported, and that had been going on for years. So
a weakening dollar is actually good news for US exporters, and
will help us address the large trade deficit and improve our balance
of trade. The dollar's weakening trend probably is not yet over.
The tide ain't turned yet. Now let's look at what has caused the
dollar to weaken.
So why does the dollar strengthen or weaken? The
answer lies in the interaction of the rate of inflation
compared to the Fed Funds rate - the interest
rate at which US banks lend to each other overnight. The Fed Funds
rate is actually a target rate, and actual interbank loan rates
can vary somewhat, but this rate is the fundamental benchmark
rate in the US banking system. In mid-2002 the rate of inflation
in the US spiked high against the Fed Funds rate. That is, the
dollar is weak against other currencies because dollar inflation
is outstripping US interest rates.
But this just begs the next question - what does
inflation have to do with the strength of the dollar? Keep in
mind that at the end of the day, currencies are just another traded
commodity. Currency traders are happy to buy or sell dollars,
as their financial interests dictate. They (even US traders) have
no loyalty to any currency. The dollar is a commodity, remember?
Traders speculate in it the same as daytraders trade stocks.
The primary way that the US borrows money is by
issuing Treasuries, which are simply loans by investors to Uncle
Sam. Cut it how you will, though, Treasury buyers are buying dollars.
When inflation is low against the dollar, the dollar is an attractive
holding, because it produces net cash flow to investors. And no
currency is more stable or solid than the dollar. But
when dollar inflation occurs, the devalued dollar cuts the yield
from owning dollars. When dollar inflation actually outstrips
interest rates, which is the state of affairs now, the dollar
becomes devalued and is worth increasingly less. If inflation
devalues the dollar at a faster rate than interest accrues on
those dollars, it actually begins to cost investors money to hold
dollars. Then investors flee from dollars.
That is precisely what is happening now. While lowering
the Fed Funds rate to its all-time low was necessary to stimulate
the US economy, a side effect was to lower it to the point that
inflation was almost bound to leapfrog interest rates. While good
for US exporters, the weak dollar also makes it more difficult
for the US government to raise money, since no one particularly
wants dollars. We have been strong-arming our rich friends (e.g.,
Saudis) to buy Treasuries, and even European countries, Japan
and others have a vested interest in buying them. After all, to
let the dollar weaken too much hurts their own economies when
we start buying less of their goods. We're still the largest single-country
market. But even to get friends and non-friends to buy Treasuries
requires the US to really sweeten the deal, raising the interest
rates paid.
The dollar will begin strengthening again when interest
rates catch up to inflation, and the real dollar momentum will
gather when inflation drops below the interest rate. This will
also make it easy for the US government to finance the national
debt, since people around the world (and here in the US) will
be more willing to save dollars. In fact, there is almost no incentive
for US citizens to park money in 2% bank accounts while inflation
eats up all of their bank interest, and then some. The following
table illustrates the facts of life when inflation rises above
interest rates:
Effects
of Inflation and
Dollar Devaluation |
|
Inflation
eats up interest earnings, so Americans save less. They put
their money into other investments (or just spend more). In
fact, savings are dreadfully low. |
| |
Foreign
investors spurn dollars because inflation eats up their interest
earnings just the same. |
| |
It
becomes harder and more expensive for the US government to
borrow and keep refinancing the deficit. |
| |
The
deficit gets harder to pay down as interest costs keep mounting.
In a few years, interest on borrowings will be a major part
of the US government budget. This hurts all of us. I'm betting
it is a huge issue in 2008. |
Actually, yes we do. What follows is not a political
rag by any means, but it is necessary to understand, since deficits
are important. When George W. Bush took office, there was a surplus
of approximately $500 Billion. There is now an $800 Billion deficit
(due in large part to his tax cuts and Iraq war), which is a $1.3
Trillion swing in the wrong direction. While it has been worse
in history, this deficit chokes our economy. We are drowning in
debt, and this does not make it any easier to convince people
to loan money to Uncle Sam. And the deficit is so huge, we can
only keep the lights on and wheels turning by massive borrowings
at accelerating interest rates.
If the dollar was weakening without the huge deficit
overhanging the economy, getting an economic recovery would be
easier. Whether you are a Republican or Democrat, the effect of
the deficit is the same. The tax cuts did not stimulate the economy
to nearly the degree predicted by the administration, although
they did run the deficit up. I would hope in the future to see
tax cuts that are more tied to productivity increases instead
of just handouts - this would be a worthwhile tax cut.
Companies that rely heavily on exports can expect
booming sales in the coming couple of years due to the weakened
dollar. Expect them to put the peddle to the metal while they
can. Manufacturers like Microsoft who have a low unit cost of
manufacturing will especially benefit. Gold stocks also tend to
do well in inflationary periods. Companies that import or that
rely heavily on imported goods for manufacturing, on the other
hand, will not do so well.
For covered call writers these concerns are not
so important, since we are not investing long term in the stocks
we buy, and we tend to hold stocks a month or less. But those
selecting portfolio stocks for the intermediate or long term (even
if principally to write calls against) definitely should pay attention
to how the weakening dollar will impact the companies' earnings.
On the other hand, covered call writers who tend to write further
out in time (3 months out or more) should probably pay attention
to each company's intermediate-term outlook. Those writing (or
buying) LEAPS calls certainly should pay attention to the weakening
dollar's impact. The CallWriter Research Page allows you to dig
in for this kind of information.
So the weakening dollar, like I said in the beginning
of this article, is not all bad. Wherever the economic wheel is
in its cycle, somebody is getting ahead and others are not. I
expect the weakening dollar to stimulate our economy and clean
up our trade deficit. Whether this will lead to a stronger stock
market remains to be seen, since the overhanging deficit will
continue to exert a negative effect on the stock market. Without
the huge deficit, the market would be poised to soar. On one thing
we all can agree, the next four years will be interesting!